Burnham beware: EU hokey-cokey risks being bad for business
On Monday this week, ahead of a Brussels summit on Friday, Andy Burnham declared to a City of London audience his intention to re-examine the UK’s relationship with the EU, placing any and all options on the table – including potentially rejoining one day. Whilst news coverage in the last few months has made it clear that the EU question was clearly on the mind of the new Prime Minister, this is the clearest statement of intent he has made since taking over the reins from Starmer.
For many in the financial services industry, Brexit was a painful and largely unwanted development. Pre-2015, the regulatory alignment which we all took for granted made everyday business and investment activity as smooth as possible. Barriers to the flow of money are the enemy of growth, so for any country to decide to obstruct activity with its closest trading market, let alone a prominent EU-member such as the UK, was regarded by many as an act of economic self-harm.
Despite this resistance however, the UK’s financial services leaders and advocates honoured the referendum result. They rolled up their sleeves and worked tirelessly with government over the last decade to shape a new framework from which the UK can continue to trade with EU counterparts as efficiently as possible and mend the bridges which were burned. The process has been far from easy, punctuated often with turbulent global events, so the prospect of rendering all that time and effort essentially pointless will not have won Burnham the thanks he may have been expecting.
For any country to thrive economically, a clear and stable landscape in which to do business is crucial. Many senior figures across the FS sector regard the post-Brexit rebuild as ‘lost years,’ i.e. time spent arguing instead of working together with EU partners to do business. Those lost years may have hurt but, ten years on, the financial services sector has adapted to the new normal. Burnham announcing his intentions to change things again, but with no firm picture of exactly what this would look like, could do further damage to the UK’s perception as a serious place to invest. A credibility of course that many in the FS sector have spent years trying to rebuild.
Burnham has now softened his stance since Monday, suggesting that the City to Westminster feedback loop is at least working. He will need to remember that whilst legislation may not always be perfect, if it continues to change every few years, few will want to invest in the UK anyway. A middle ground, which gives the UK a Swiss-style set-up, could potentially be reached without angering the significant ‘out means out’ campaigners. Still, whilst a vocal public reaction from senior financial services figures is, so far, lacking, the notion that we could simply rejoin the EU and get as good a deal as we had previously is fooling nobody. Regardless of where people stand on the ideological battlelines, no one can really say for sure anymore whether rejoining the EU would give the UK a better economic outlook – and that is the real problem Burnham faces.