Skip to main content

A year in the making, a decade to deliver

commuters
By Jack Olins
17 November 2026
Public Affairs & Government Relations
youth unemployment
News

Almost a year after Alan Milburn was tasked with confronting Britain’s growing youth unemployment problem, his long-awaited review has finally landed. Few would dispute the scale of the challenge he has spent the past year examining, almost one million young people are now not in education, employment or training, prompting Milburn to warn that Britain has reached a “fork in the road moment” and call for a “complete system reset”. His ambition is equally bold, seeking to reduce the NEET rate from 13% to 5% by 2036.

The lengthy build-up means few details have come as a surprise to Westminster. Recommendations have been heavily trailed, and potentially rebellious Labour MPs are aware of some of the more politically difficult proposals. The report’s publication means attention shifts from Milburn’s diagnosis to the government’s response and implementation.

The government must deal with some uncomfortable conclusions in Milburn’s report. He has recommended investing billions upfront in employment support, alongside reductions in employer National Insurance for young workers. The latter is particularly awkward given Labour increased employer NICs under Sir Keir Starmer, compounded by concerns from businesses around changes to employment law. 

There is also political difficulty in proposals to move under-25s away from PIP and the health element of Universal Credit towards a new youth allowance, alongside more intensive employment support. Milburn accepts that some young people could initially receive less financial support, while the wider reforms may require up to £6 billion of additional employment spending and are not expected to generate savings for at least a decade.

This creates a difficult balancing act between the Labour backbenches and the markets. The Left will be nervous about benefit reductions, while the Treasury must confront demands for tax cuts and significant upfront spending with no immediate fiscal dividend. 

So far, however, the political landing has been considerably softer than Labour's previous attempt at welfare reform. Opposition among Labour MPs appears largely confined to the party's usual suspects as the government has spent weeks preparing the Parliamentary Labour Party for the proposals. 

The opposition attack has seen the Conservatives criticise the package for relying on the “expensive hand of the state”, while both the Conservatives and Reform UK can point to Milburn’s NICs recommendation as evidence that Labour’s tax rises have damaged employment.

For Andy Burnham, this is increasingly becoming a test of political ownership – he appears determined to control the politics before implementing the policy. The government is expected to broadly accept Milburn’s direction while taking longer over the most difficult questions, with legislation expected next year.

This may explain the relatively calm response so far. However, the fight over welfare reform was one of the issues that helped destabilise Starmer’s government, with many leading rebels now in the Cabinet. The real political test will come when individual losers from the new system become clear. 

Burnham has successfully managed the launch, but implementing Milburn’s “complete reset” without reopening Labour’s welfare wounds will be considerably harder.