Skip to main content

Succession before crisis: Why boards need to plan for the unexpected

empty boardroom
By Elisabeth Cowell
17 November 2026
Crisis, Special Situations & Litigation
Strategy & Corporate Communications
CEO
News

In a week when Nvidia found itself at the centre of one of the business world’s biggest scandals in recent memory, the crisis also brought another, less sensational but no less important, boardroom issue sharply into focus: what happens when the person most closely associated with a company is suddenly no longer there?

Perhaps one of the most surprising revelations to emerge was that the world’s second most valuable company, listed for 27 years, did not appear to have a seasoned successor ready to step seamlessly into the role of CEO following Jensen Huang’s departure.

Nvidia’s announcement that its board would initiate a search for a permanent Chief Executive Officer, considering both internal and external candidates, made the challenge particularly visible. For a business so closely associated with its founder and CEO, this story provides a powerful reminder that succession planning cannot begin when a departure becomes inevitable. It needs to start long before it is necessary.

This is particularly important for founder-led businesses. Founders can embody a company’s history, culture, strategy, relationships and credibility. Those qualities do not automatically transfer with a job title and the more closely the company’s identity and investment case are tied to one person, the greater the potential disruption when that individual leaves.

So, what lessons should boards and senior leaders take from a case such as this?

The best time to discuss succession is when you don’t need to

Retirement has traditionally been the most obvious trigger for succession planning and remains one of the most common scenarios we are briefed to prepare for. Still, it is only one of many with illness, reputational crises, unexpected resignations, changes of control and personal circumstances all forcing leadership change with little or no warning. Research by Corporate Board Member in 2025 found that only 41% of nearly 100 directors surveyed felt “very well prepared” for a sudden CEO departure.

With this in mind, the question for boards therefore should not simply be “who replaces the CEO when they retire but “could we change CEO tomorrow without fundamentally changing the market’s view of the company?” 

Key-person risk can quickly become valuation risk

The more a company’s strategy, customer relationships, investor confidence and corporate identity become associated with one person, the greater the transition risk. Within our client base we regularly see first-hand through our M&A and IPO work the significant value that can be created by a strong CEO with a clear, compelling vision. In one such case this year, this resulted in the biggest retail fundraise achieved in the past five years.  Exceptional CEOs can create enormous value but great boards make sure that value does not leave with them.

That means succession planning should start by identifying where institutional value and influence actually reside: 

  • Who owns the most important customer, government and stakeholder relationships?
  • Who can credibly articulate the strategy to investors?
  • Who understands the critical operational dependencies?
  • Who has the credibility to lead through a crisis?
  • Who can withstand the scrutiny that comes with becoming the public face of the business?
  • How much of the company’s reputation rests with one individual? 

Answering those questions can reveal concentrations of risk long before succession becomes an immediate issue. 

Investors need to know more than boards perhaps realise

Succession communications require nuance. Companies understandably don't want to announce that “X is our next CEO” years before a transition takes place, but there is considerable ground between naming a successor and giving investors no visibility of the leadership depth beneath the CEO. 

Companies can build confidence over time by demonstrating the quality and breadth of the senior management team across their communications. For listed businesses, Capital Markets Days can be particularly valuable, giving divisional and functional leaders greater exposure to investors and allowing the market to see that the investment case extends beyond a single individual.

Media engagement, investor meetings, corporate reporting and digital channels can all play a similar role. 

The objective should be simple: when succession eventually happens, it should feel like the next chapter of the same investment story, rather than the beginning of an entirely new one.

Ultimately, succession is not simply a people or governance issue. It is about protecting continuity, confidence and corporate value. The best boards will have answered the question of what happens tomorrow long before tomorrow arrives.